America’s Most Unique Private Clubs (That Aren’t Golf-Related)

by | Jun 1, 2025

There’s a world of private clubs most people will never hear about — and that’s exactly how their members like it.

While golf usually gets the attention, some of the most exclusive and offbeat private communities in America are defined not by tee times, but by cabins, cocktails, and creativity. 

Want to sip wine at a hidden estate in Charlottesville? Hike with a world-class chef in the Smokies? Hobnob with resident artists in the rolling hills of Georgia? Or unwind with jazz by candlelight at an Adirondack lodge once owned by Rockefeller?

Here’s a curated look at some of the most exclusive and under-the-radar private clubs east of the Mississippi that offer luxury and lifestyle access beyond the fairway.

Walland, Tennessee

Not just a resort — this is a luxury mountain sanctuary. With private membership options, Blackberry offers access to its wine cellar, wellness programs, and Appalachian culinary legacy. Think guided forest bathing, clay shooting, and Michelin-level tasting menus.

Rabun Gap, Georgia

This hidden artist colony and residency program offers secluded cabins, private exhibitions, and a nature-immersed creative culture that few know exists. VIP donors and patrons enjoy access to invite-only salons and retreats.

Southampton, New York

Private surf, sand, and cabana culture at its absolute peak. This ultra-secretive beach club is invite-only and beloved by East Coast aristocracy for its understated elegance.

Millbrook, New York

A members-only countryside sporting club offering fly-fishing, upland bird hunting, and shooting sports in an old-world lodge setting. It’s heritage Americana, perfected.

Charlottesville, Virginia

A quietly growing society of wine collectors, investors, and oenophiles with access to Boisset’s rare reserves, private events, and seasonal gatherings at partner vineyards across the East.

Saranac Lake, New York (Adirondacks)

A former Rockefeller Great Camp turned private retreat with a members-only tier. It’s rustic luxury, complete with mahogany boats, black-tie dinners, and no cell service in sight.

Waynesville, North Carolina

Perched on the edge of Great Smoky Mountains National Park, this invitation-only club mixes remote cabin hospitality with 5-star cuisine, guided hikes, and roaring fireplaces.